Beneath A Steel Sky - Remastered Preview

Charles Cecil on resurrecting the classic adventure.

If we had a new point-and-click adventure game for every time someone said: "That was definitely the last point-and-click adventure game," then we'd pretty much be where we are today. Long pronounced dead, the adventure game never really departed. From Broken Sword 4 to Grim Fandango to Zack & Wiki, new releases in the genre may be sparse but they are undeniably steady. And as a slew of LucasArts and Sierra classics make their way onto the Steam download service, just as Monkey Island introduces a new generation of console gamers to insult sword-fighting, the genre is enjoying, if not a resurrection, then certainly something of a resurgence.

Beneath A Steel Sky (BASS) is the latest venerable adventure game to undergo a nip and a tuck in preparation for re-release. While less iconic than some of the LucasArts big-hitters, it is nevertheless the most widely played adventure game of all time. Nine years after its original release in 1994, British developer Revolution Software released the game's source code as freeware, to be offered for free to all users of ScummVM, the popular adventure game emulator. As a result, millions have played it. So why now choose to bring it to the iPhone? And why charge players for the privilege? By combining a mobile telephone, a map and a diary, we solved these puzzles and more at a meeting with the game's creator and MD of Revolution Software, Charles Cecil. And when it comes to talking to the grandfather of the adventure game about his genre's future, passions run high.

'Beneath A Steel Sky - Remastered' Screenshot 1

The new logo.

"Everything is f***ed up." Something dark flashes behind Cecil's normally kind eyes and his bald pate turns a darker shade of rosy. "When it comes to retail, everything is f***ed up, all the way down the line. If we sell a game in a shop, the retailer takes 40 per cent of the cover price, the format holder takes 15 per cent and the publisher pays us 20 per cent of what's left. That money has to be set against our development costs, so you can imagine how many copies of a game we have to sell to recoup. But on iPhone we receive 70 per cent of the game price immediately and we can sell direct to our audience. So we can charge a fraction of the price of a boxed product."

So is this re-release just a quick way to make a quicker buck? "Not at all. We've put a lot of effort into this BASS port," he explains. "It's not shovelware. As with Broken Sword: Director's Cut, we've added content that I think makes it a very justifiable and worthwhile project." That new content includes, amongst other things, fully animated cut-scenes, notable for being created by renowned comic book artist Dave Gibbons. In motion the sequences are beautiful, perfectly capturing the game's dystopian ambiance. But the proposed $2-3 asking price for the game isn't all being spent on new art and re-sampled dialogue. Rather, as Cecil is quick to point out, buyers are investing in the genre's future.

"Yes, you can jailbreak your phone and play the game for free. But if you like the game and like the kind of games we make, then pay us a little bit of money and, if it's a big enough success, we can reinvest the funds. We can start to look at a potential BASS sequel. You know, I think a massive part of the piracy problem is due to a broken-down relationship between game makers and consumers. There's no respect between the two parties anymore. So I'm very excited at the prospect of repairing the relationship. I think this is the model we'll take with our future games. If you like adventures and like what we write, then please work with us. We're looking at ways of including fans names in future games and so on. It's more exciting than ever before. It reminds me of the early eighties where anything seemed possible for smaller game-makers."

Speaking of the 1980s, we ask Charles to describe that period for him as a game-maker, and the emergence of the genre in which he'd make his name. "I wrote my first game in 1981. At the time I was studying mechanical engineering on a university course sponsored by Ford. Through that sponsorship program I met Richard Turner, a coder who invited me to make some games with him. I'd spend two weeks writing a game and then Richard would take two weeks to code it. The moment the game was finished we'd phone up WH Smith, the biggest videogame retailer at the time, and convince them to place an order for 5000 copies. Then we'd called up the local printer, ask them to ship a batch of covers down to the tape duplication company in Banbury and then they would ship the packaged games to WH Smith. It would be three phone calls and then we'd have £40-50,000 in the bank. We were essentially students. It was insane."

While Cecil is eager to point out that the pair was turning out good products at the time, he's the first to admit that their success owed a lot to timing. "We were extremely fortunate to be making games at that particular point in history. As soon as the big American companies got involved they blew us out of the water and it became clear just how fortunate we'd been. After that I worked for US Gold and then Activision. After a while Activision started running into some difficulties and told me that I would have to move onto a part-time contract. I asked them if I could start up my own development studio, they agreed and Revolution was born."

'Beneath A Steel Sky - Remastered' Screenshot 2

The original BASS as it appears on ScummVM.

Two days a week Cecil worked his day-job at Activison, while the other three were spent setting up the new company. These early days were unglamorous. "Our premises were above a fruit shop in Hull. It was so cold. We had a gas heater that spat out terrible fumes. In the middle of winter we either closed the window and turned the gas off, or closed the window and turned the gas on. Our coders wore fingerless gloves to type." But far from resenting this Dickensian set-up, Cecil believes it provided the kind of environment in which start-ups flourish. "I think that too much money can be a dangerous thing for a start-up developer. You look at the companies that start with a bang and they normally go with a bang."

Mirrorsoft, Robert Maxwell's emerging videogame publishing company, supported Revolution's first game. "Sean Brennan [who now works for Bethesda] was deputy managing director at Mirrorsoft and was one of the key people in convincing me to set up Revolution. He assured me that they'd support us if we set up a studio and was true to his word. Our first game was codenamed, Vengeance, which is obviously a s***ty name. But as development drew to a close we couldn't settle on anything we liked. In the end I gave Alison Beasley, head of Mirrorsoft marketing at the time, a list of possible titles and asked her to choose between them. Of course, she picked out the one joke entry I added to the bottom of the list: Lure of the Temptress." When I explained that there was neither any luring nor a temptress in the game she suggested we add them sharpish. So we rewrote the story and characters to fit the name, adding a month to development time."

Following the success of Lure of the Temptress, Revolution started work on Beneath A Steel Sky, a game that came about via collaboration with Dave Gibbons, an artist most famous for his work with Alan Moore on the seminal graphic novel, Watchmen. "I knew Dave because, while at Activison, we'd been in discussions to license a Watchmen game. I loved the idea of collaborating with someone who was so experienced and talented within a different medium, so convinced him to come and work with us. We were now in a slightly more upmarket, salubrious office in Hull, and Dave would come up via train to work on the story with us. He designed all of the characters and then drew the backgrounds in pencil." These pencil sketches were then coloured by one of Gibbons' friends, Les Pace, before being scanned in and animated by the team, giving the game its unique look.

Dave Cummins, who, alongside Cecil, worked on Lure of the Temptress and Revolution's later hit, Broken Sword, wrote the dialogue for the game. "The tone of our early games was born from a tension between Dave and I. He wanted to be more flippant with dialogue, while I wanted to be more serious. That was always our vision, to find the middle ground between Sierra's ridiculously earnest stories and the slapstick comedy of the LucasArts titles but I think our personalities and approaches emphasized the tension."

Set in an Australia, BASS' story and setting is one of the key reasons for the game's loyal and vociferous fanbase. But the scenario was born from a simple twist on convention: "We liked the idea of reversing the natural order of cities, whereby the higher you are the more status you have. Our concept was that, in a dystopian society were pollution rises, you'd have the richest people living in the lowest areas as, the higher you rise, the more scummy the environment became. Of course, at the time we all loved Blade Runner and Alien and Terminator, the three really big science-fiction films of the era, and they were a big influence."

The game cost about £40,000 to make, a huge amount of money for Cecil at the time, whose first games at Arctic Software had cost around £200 a title. However, just as the game was entering its final stages, Mirrorsoft's owner, Robert Maxwell, died in a yachting accident. Almost overnight the powerhouse publisher went into administration with most of the staff either transferring to Acclaim or Virgin. Nevertheless, the game sold extremely well at retail, managing between 3-400,000 copies, almost all of which were from Europe. For Cecil, it was reward for what had been a difficult development.

'Beneath A Steel Sky - Remastered' Screenshot 3

The iPhone comes first, but Revolution Pocket's announcement release mentions the possibility of other handheld formats, including Android, DSiWare and PSPgo.

"I wasn't particularly realistic about the scope of the game," he admits. "I'm a bit of an autocrat. I believe you ideally have one person driving the vision and that, if you make a mistake, you go back and change it. You make the best decision you can at the start but as the game progresses you have to be willing to go back and change things. Servicing those changes was hard work at times. But you know, videogames are generally just a bitch to finish. BASS wasn't particularly unique in that regard. I'm immensely proud of what we achieved."

BASS' re-release on iPhone segues neatly with the general resurgence of the point-and-click adventure. But for Cecil, the renaissance is due to more than mere nostalgia; its impetus is technological. "I think the resurgence is down to the fact that the hardware spec of these smaller devices is forcing developers back to basics, to push the processor and to make the most of the graphics; we don't have the benefit of gigabytes of RAM. I see the market really diverging between these hundred million dollar developed games, and much simpler games that require the skills that we had back in the eighties."

So has the widening of technical boundaries brought with it a more lazy style of game development? "No, not at all," he says. "You just have more diverse types of game. Technology always opens up new possibilities, but limitations provide helpful constraints, forcing you to innovate within the boundaries. Revolution was formed in 1990 with me wanting to go back to those early days, where teams were small and boundaries were tight. But here today, with the iPhone and Flash platforms it feels like that time again. The difference is that we're now armed with 25 years of game development experience. As such, I hope we can grasp those opportunities in a way that we were unable to the first time."

Beneath A Steel Sky - Remastered is due out for iPhone and iPod Touch this autumn, and may also appear on other formats.

Comments (52) Latest comment 3 years ago

Comments threads automatically close after 30 days, but please feel free to continue chatting on the forum!

  • CYBER-WOO #1 3 years ago

    I had this on the PC back in in the day and loved every minute!
    Edited by 1 at 30/07/09 @ 07:21
  • siro #2 3 years ago

    A remastered version on iphone only (for now?). Seems a bit of a waste considering that many fans of the original won't have one. I'd like to play it, so please bring it to one of the major platforms. :)
  • dominalien #3 3 years ago

    Is it just me or do the blocky 320x200 gfx look better than the new ones? Applies to this one, but just as much to MISE.
  • Tonka #4 3 years ago

    Isn't there a SCUMM VM for the iPhone?
  • comissars_handgun #5 3 years ago

    There is SCUMM VM for the iPhone, but you need to jailbreak your phone to use it. I'd gladly pay a couple of quid to get an enhanced version though, and I can't be bothered with jailbreaking.
  • dominalien #6 3 years ago

    yes there is.

    EDIT: beaten to it. Yes, it has to be jailbroken. Which is a bit of a chore.

    RANDOM RANT: This is why I actually prefer my PSP to the iPhone as a media device. With the PSP, I can just sit in front of any computer, fire up Handbrake, convert some movies, and then copy them along with some music to the memory card. With the iPhone, I have to use iTunes, with the whole syncing, etc. The closed platform is a pain :-(
    Edited by 1 at 30/07/09 @ 07:58
  • Verwandlung #7 3 years ago

    I was excited until i saw the platform :(
  • Domovoi #8 3 years ago

    Sounds great, but I'll be damned if I buy a smartphone, and I already own a DS so I have no interest in DSi. PC, console, DS, sure, but it's not out for those. So... I guess Charles missed all the instabuy platforms for me, personally.
  • DDevil #9 3 years ago

    I must have completed BASS 10 times. I'm sure I'll do it again.
  • redneon Verified Programmer, SUMO Digital #10 3 years ago

  • Laserbream #11 3 years ago

    Nice interview! I hadn't realised Capt'n Bob was involved in the games business.
  • matrim83 #12 3 years ago

    Wasnt this abandonware?
  • Xerx3s #13 3 years ago

    This probably won't handle very well on mobile devices. I've got scummvm on mine and it just doesn't feel right. The finger and such is just too big, actions too complex, etc. I can't imagine that an even smaller screen would improve that. The DS version works because they use a pen, which is far more like a mouse than finger controls.
    Edited by 1 at 30/07/09 @ 08:50
  • hiddenranbir #14 3 years ago

    I played this thanks to GoG!
  • Xerx3s #15 3 years ago

    Yeah, it's free on gog btw. Or at least it used to be when I signed up.
  • kangarootoo #16 3 years ago

    I was waffling on in the Ubi piracy thread about DLC being more expensive because of the number of middlemen.

    This...

    ""Everything is f***ed up." Something dark flashes behind Cecil's normally kind eyes and his bald pate turns a darker shade of rosy. "When it comes to retail, everything is f***ed up, all the way down the line. If we sell a game in a shop, the retailer takes 40 per cent of the cover price, the format holder takes 15 per cent and the publisher pays us 20 per cent of what's left. That money has to be set against our development costs, so you can imagine how many copies of a game we have to sell to recoup. But on iPhone we receive 70 per cent of the game price immediately and we can sell direct to our audience. So we can charge a fraction of the price of a boxed product.""

    is exactly what I was on about. Change the delivery chain, and prices will come down.
  • septimus #17 3 years ago

    Still have this through GOG.com (free) but only ever completed it on the Amiga. Great games and definitely worth a few dollars to get a nicer version for my iPhone... which is currently in its box with a shattered screen. They aren't resilient to concrete steps :(
  • Flying_Pig #18 3 years ago

    Currently enjoying Monkey Island on my iPhone, and I loved BASS, so am pretty excited by this.

    More please!
  • dominalien #19 3 years ago

    Well if Sony bring out a PSP device to rival I-Phone (as has been reported) then I think a lot of people will feel the same as you.

    Provided that Sony keep the current method of access to the memory and don't go all iTunes on us. Which may happen as they're notoriously unable to keep the platform secure as is. Of course, the software will be Windows-only.
  • dominalien #20 3 years ago

  • Ranger101 #21 3 years ago

    "Wasnt this abandonware? "

    Nope, it's freeware now.

    You can download it legally for free from the ScummVM website.

    Revolution are nice like that.

    (Abandonware is technically still copyright infringement, although more of a grey area as the Copyright holder is out of business or the copyright ownership situation is forgotton/unclear).
    Edited by 1 at 30/07/09 @ 09:59
  • MENTAL1ST Verified Senior Software Engineer, Picsel UK Ltd. #22 3 years ago

    I started playing BASS recently on ScummVM for Wii. The trouble was, I had to stop because the godawful sample quality of all the speech and sound effects were hurting my ears.

    As such, I'll gladly pay a couple of quid for this, just like I did with Monkey Island last weekend. Hopefully Revolution will make their control system a bit less irritating than Lucasarts did.
  • MENTAL1ST Verified Senior Software Engineer, Picsel UK Ltd. #23 3 years ago

    This probably won't handle very well on mobile devices. I've got scummvm on mine and it just doesn't feel right. The finger and such is just too big, actions too complex, etc.

    Hmmm... maybe lucasarts were right after all.

    Can anyone comment on how Flight of the Amazon Queen works on iPhone?
  • Moribundman #24 3 years ago

    Nice to see someone openly touting Android as a potential platform. I would imagine that when you have a PC and an iPhone version its not the hardest job in the world to convert... And there's a free unofficially supported SCUMMVM app in the android store that got me right back into point and click even before SMI:SE was announced (not that my old point and clicks ever really went away... ;-)
  • GreyScale #25 3 years ago

    Nice as it is to see old classics being re-vamped and available, there is a little voice in the back of my head which is telling me that it is just another excuse for ancient games being re-hashed and sold again for profit by tapping into the iPhone retro niche market (which is currently quite small, but I can easily see it being flooded with cash-in retro reissues in the future - Sega seem to already be having a crack at this, and Capcom with their rubbish MegaMan port).
  • Domovoi #26 3 years ago

    There's no such thing as abandonware. It's not even a grey area: it's just illegal.
  • StooMonster #27 3 years ago

    Crofto says since the I-Phone/Pod are laughably and unjustifiably overpriced

    If iPhone and iPod were overpriced they would not sell, however, they sell tens of millions so the price is right. Apple's strategy is to create high margin goods at a price the market supports in order to increase shareholder value; for example it was reported this week that iPhone has a 60% margin. Apple has more cash in the bank than Microsoft, and is now 70% of its market capitalisation too; Apple's strategy is obviously working, so the iPhone/iPod is justifiably priced.
  • poopmonster #28 3 years ago

    Monkey Island works well on iPhone - better than SCUMM VM, so there's no reason BASS shouldn't.
  • StooMonster #29 3 years ago

    Domovoi: that's not strictly true, depends on who owns it.

    For example, if a company owned some intellectual property such as an old 8-bit game but ceased trading and the assets (i.e. the games) were not sold before the company closed then the asset ownership reverts to "the Crown", even if it's valued at nothing, that's how I understand it to work in the UK.

    Anyone can contact the right department in the UK government and buy these defunct assets (e.g. old games from defunct publishers); although they will charge what they think is fair market value, so if you plan to revitalise an old 8-bit game as new title they'll probably charge a lot.

    BASS on the other hand, the authors/creators retailed the copyright but have said that the game is free for anyone to download and use.
  • XdarXideX #30 3 years ago

    @mentalist

    "Can anyone comment on how Flight of the Amazon Queen works on iPhone?"

    Yeah it's a nightmare... you use the touch screen as though you're moving a mouse on a mat. By that I mean the cursor doesn't follow your finger, but instead moves in the direction you swipe your finger from anywhere on the screen. You have to tap to "click" the "mouse" too... it's pretty shit. But at least it's a decent working version of FOTAQ.

    I'm quite excited about BASS. I didn't buy Monkey Island on iphone due to the fact I bought it on XBLA. BASS is one of my all time favorite P&Cs so I'll happily buy it on iphone! I do wish they would have considered a Special Edition on XBLA though.
  • GreyScale #31 3 years ago

    @MrED209

    I am happy to pay cash money for decent updated versions of old games - the recent Monkey Island remake showed how it should be done. Hopefully with BASS it will be the same.

    What I am worried about is unscrupulous companies seeing this gap in the market and spamming it with endless crap ports of ancient games with no added value. It riles me even more when I consider that they are potentially exploiting our love of classic old games to maximise their own profits while putting in as little effort as possible.

    I'm kinda cynical that way I guess.
  • Ranger101 #32 3 years ago

    "There's no such thing as abandonware. It's not even a grey area: it's just illegal. "

    Nope. There is a grey area. Copyright law isn't straight forward enough for a statement like that.

    On an extreme case, technically, pirating a 'foreign' game that hasn't been released in the UK (and has no company representation in the UK) is not copyright infringement until the company 'releases' it in the UK or claims ownership for it here. This is a gross oversimplification, but the principal is present enough to give you an example of a grey area.

    StooMonster's example is another good one. IP Laywers make a lot of money because of how complicated Copyright and IP Laws are.
  • smirny #33 3 years ago

    what with currently very much enjoying monkey island on 360, i'd relish the chance to play BASS again on live arcade, pleeeeeeeaaaaassssseeee!!
  • Pac-man-ate-my-wife #34 3 years ago

    It's great that old classics such as these are getting a new lease of life and, more importantly, the developers are getting the lion's share of cash. It's also great that the iPhone is offering a platform whereby indie devs can compete against the big boys on an equal playing field. There are fears that shovelware ports (I'm looking at you Sega) will become the norm so I hope that developers like this who are willing to take time and effort to deliver an excellent experience for the platform iPhone are rewarded accordingly. Thankfully has a wonderful range of games from the fully featured titles like Let's Golf and Real Racing, to more experimental titles like Eliss and :Shift:, all at great prices that mean you can take a punt without much risk.

    As for the nonsense above about putting video onto the iPhone: you can rip DVDs and set up iTunes to automatically add them to your library, it's really not that big an issue as some might make out. It's a one step more than dragging and dropping, but most iPhone users will be using iTunes to manage their device so I don't think it's a massive problem.
  • MENTAL1ST Verified Senior Software Engineer, Picsel UK Ltd. #35 3 years ago

    @XdarXideX

    Monkey Island is pretty much the same. Maybe the touchscreen-as-laptop-trackpad paradigm is just something we'll have to get used to. To be honest, my main problems with monkey island's controls are the spotty double-tap detection and the fact that moving your finger over the inventory icon whilst dragging the cursor about opens it up when you clearly don't want it to. I'm sure both of these problems could be sorted with a stricter usability QA cycle.
    Edited by 1 at 30/07/09 @ 10:56
  • Horse #36 3 years ago

    I loved this game! Definitely going to buy the new version. But that revamped logo?! It's ruined! At least take the horrible blue 'remastered' text out of the frame and suspend it beneath the original frame!
  • Pac-man-ate-my-wife #37 3 years ago

    @ MrED209

    If you know how to rip you know how to convert.

    I'm not saying it doesn't take a wee bit longer, just that it's really not a big deal. Anyone with the nouse to rip a DVD should be able to convert it to suitable format without any problem.
  • Domovoi #38 3 years ago

    What I am worried about is unscrupulous companies seeing this gap in the market and spamming it with endless crap ports of ancient games with no added value. It riles me even more when I consider that they are potentially exploiting our love of classic old games to maximise their own profits while putting in as little effort as possible.

    Arguably, LucasArts has done this by releasing a bunch of their old games on Steam. It allowed me to finally play The Dig for a measly €3,99. Why anyone can possibly think that is a bad thing is beyond me.
  • lucky_jim #39 3 years ago

    A legendarily great adventure game is coming to a new format for the price of a speccy budget title, and people are finding reasons to complain? Ok I'm biased cos BaSS is in my top 5 favourite ever games list, but I don't see how anyone could think this is anything but great news!
  • GamesConnoisseur #40 3 years ago

    I for one will certainly be getting BASS on my iPhone, Monkey Island works fine aside from getting used to the control method and I would be delighted to be able to access graphic adventures on the move! Just be sure I dont do it while driving my car!
  • GreyScale #41 3 years ago

    I don't buy any of those games, ever. I imagine you don't either. So I ask again - where's the actual harm?

    Not sure what this means exactly, where did I say this was harming anyone? And since when did you and I represent the entire iPhone gaming demographic?

    My point is that I don't want to see cynical exploitative shovelware flooding the market, which is very easy to do with retro gaming as it takes advantage of people's emotive nostalgia and can be produced for a fraction of the cost of an original title.
  • chudders #42 3 years ago

    Excellent interview by the way. It was fascinating to hear how game studios were doing it way back when I was a lad - it gives me a twitch in the loins to think that I was part of gaming's infancy.





  • Killerbee #43 3 years ago

    Great game. Definitely one of my favourites on the Amiga.

    I was pretty excited to see this article and the possibility of a remastered version - until I read "iPhone".

    Please do a version for a proper console or handheld, eh?
  • Rubarack #44 3 years ago

    You know, I think a massive part of the piracy problem is due to a broken-down relationship between game makers and consumers. There's no respect between the two parties anymore. So I'm very excited at the prospect of repairing the relationship. I think this is the model we'll take with our future games.

    I think he's absolutely bang on here. When I buy a game it's really because I respect the developers and want them to be able to carry on what they do. But dealing with this broken supply chain and greedy disrespectful publishers diminishes this a lot. But where the majority of the money goes to a developer that clearly deserves respect it feels like an easy and obvious choice.
  • Verwandlung #45 3 years ago

  • StooMonster #46 3 years ago

    MilkybKid1985: for plenty of products retailers get 50% of retail price, the 40% outlined is probably about right for games.
    Edited by 1 at 30/07/09 @ 14:42
  • Horse #47 3 years ago

    @MrEd209 I never saw the original logo - what's wrong with that one?

    Maybe a bit of rose-tinted glasses on my part, but the original just has better proportions, and that 'remastered' text is completely out of keeping with the style of the original.
  • space_ace #48 3 years ago

    There's no respect between the two parties anymore.

    just ask activision
  • electrolite #49 3 years ago

    Yeah, but it won't be the same without coming on 48 (approx) floppy discs!
  • penhalion #50 3 years ago

    I had this back in the day. It was great. I have no interest in playing it again however, so who exactly is this aimed at?
  • Cthulhu_X #51 3 years ago

    Banner on the main page shows Broken Sword 4 :p
  • Gecks #52 3 years ago

    @StooMonster
    "For example, if a company owned some intellectual property such as an old 8-bit game but ceased trading and the assets (i.e. the games) were not sold before the company closed then the asset ownership reverts to "the Crown", even if it's valued at nothing, that's how I understand it to work in the UK."

    well, even if that was the case, "the crown" would own the copyright, so it's still not legal to distribute/download.

    assuming 'abandonware' was technically a legal possibility, i don't know of a single example of an 'abandonware' game that is actually 'abandoned' in this way. intellectual rights for old games are typically bought up by someone or other in the event that the original company ceases trading, even if they don't do anything with them.

    those seeking out and distributing abandonware never, ever do this sort of due-diligence anyway, so it's a moot point.
    Edited by 1 at 05/08/09 @ 15:36